Critique Commands

Critiques are criticisms of solutions. They track issues found during review, with severity levels and a lifecycle: open, addressed, valid, or dismissed. Critiques can reference specific files and lines.

`jjj critique new`

Add a critique to a solution.

jjj critique new <solution_id> <title> [OPTIONS]

Flag	Type	Default	Description
`--severity`	string	`medium`	Severity: low, medium, high, critical
`--file`	string		File path for code-level critique
`--line`	integer		Line number for code-level critique
`--reviewer`	string		Mark as a review request from this reviewer (e.g., `@alice`)

When --reviewer is specified, the critique is created as a review request. The reviewer field indicates which reviewer should address this critique. This unifies the concepts of review requests and critiques into a single model.

jjj init
jjj problem new "Fix login flow"
jjj solution new "Refactor auth handler" --problem "Fix login"
jjj critique new "Refactor auth" "Missing error handling" --severity high
jjj critique new "Refactor auth" "Unused import" --severity low --file src/auth.rs --line 3
jjj critique list

`jjj critique list`

List critiques.

jjj critique list [OPTIONS]

Flag	Type	Description
`--solution`	string	Filter by solution
`--status`	string	Filter by status (open, addressed, valid, dismissed)
`--reviewer`	string	Filter by reviewer (e.g., `@alice`)
`--search`	string	Search critiques by title text
`--json`	bool	Output in JSON format

jjj critique list --solution "Refactor auth"
jjj critique list --status open
jjj critique list --json

`jjj critique show`

Show critique details.

jjj critique show <critique_id> [OPTIONS]

Flag	Type	Description
`--json`	bool	Output in JSON format

jjj critique show "Missing error"
jjj critique show "Missing error" --json

`jjj critique edit`

Edit critique details.

jjj critique edit <critique_id> [OPTIONS]

Flag	Type	Description
`--title`	string	New title
`--severity`	string	New severity (low, medium, high, critical)
`--status`	string	New status (open, addressed, valid, dismissed)

jjj critique edit "Missing error" --severity critical --title "Missing error handling in auth"

`jjj critique address`

Mark a critique as addressed (the solution was modified to fix the issue).

jjj critique address <critique_id>

jjj critique address "Missing error"

`jjj critique validate`

Validate a critique (confirm it is correct; the solution should be refuted).

jjj critique validate <critique_id>

jjj critique validate "Missing error"

`jjj critique dismiss`

Dismiss a critique (incorrect or irrelevant).

jjj critique dismiss <critique_id>

jjj critique dismiss "Unused import"

`jjj critique reply`

Reply to a critique.

jjj critique reply <critique_id> <body>

jjj critique reply "Missing error" "Fixed in latest change, added error handling for all auth paths"